Saturday, May 3, 2014

Piketty Review from Nassim Taleb: The Pikettistas' Reasoning Error

This is a great review from Taleb regarding Piketty's "Capitlal:

1) I am appalled to see how economists are making the mistake of interpretation in the Piketty craze (which we showed contains questionable measurement --note: the paper is about measurement & we've been working on it for a long time; it is not about Piketty but we believe that this applies to his work). His measure of inequality could be inconsistent across samples, so under fat tails, with his measure,Average(Inequality(A)+Inequality(B)) < Inequality(A+B). It can rise over time as populations get larger (under fat tails), or rise simply from model error or breadth of the measurement.
2) But the problem is more severe than his sloppy empiricism, it is at the purely logical level: if the process is fat tailed, then wealth is generated at the top, which means increases in wealth lead to increases of measured inequality. Within population wealth creation is a series of small probability bets. So it is natural that the pool of wealth (measured in years of spending, as Piketty does) increases with wealth. Consider 100 people, for a tail α that corresponds to our measurement, the additional wealth should come come 1 person, which the remaining bottom 50 contributing nothing. It is not a zero sum gain: eliminate that person, and there will be almost no wealth increases. In fact the rest are already benefiting from the contribution of the minority. (I do not consider overpaid corporate managers and bankers with no skin-in-the-game and such empty suits as wealth contributors, but rather the product of warped incentives; I am talking about real people, risk takers like entrepreneurs).
A wealth tax meaning to punish the wealth generator is absurd: since the payoff is severely clipped on the upside, it would be a lunacy to be a risk taker with small probability bets, with wins of 20 (after tax) rather than 100, then disburse all savings progressively in wealth tax. The optimal strategy is to go become an academic or a French-style civil servant, the anti-wealth generators. To see the cross-sectional problem temporally: Compare someone with lumpy payoffs say an entrepreneur who makes $4.5 million every 20 years to a professor like Krugman who earns the same total over the period ($225K in taxpayer-funded income). The entrepreneur over the VERY SAME income ends up paying 75% in taxes, plus wealth tax on the rest while the rent-seeking tenured academic who doesn't contribute to wealth formation pays, say 30%.)
The problem with economists is that they are not (with very few exceptions) familiar with fat tails and make general statements that violate the true probabilistic payoff. In Mediocristan changes over time are the result of the collective contributions of the center, the middle. In Extremistan these changes come from the tails. Sorry, if you don't like it but that is purely mathematical
3) Worry about skin in the game, not inequality. Worry about equality in opportunity not outcome. Worry about the powerful corporations taking over the system via lobbyists and blocking artisans. Worry about the class of privileged mandarins-WNSITG (with no skin in the game) taking over the system via "grandes ecoles"...
PS- The top is unstable. In The Black Swan I explain that the "fairness" of the fat tailed world is that, in the absence of government intervention to support the powerful, the wealthy and powerful becomes more fragile and likely to be displaced. The top is the US is not the same in 2014 as it was in 1984, and it is a healthy system. In places with cronism (Europe), the top is sticky.
PPS- Asset Price Inflation. It would be interesting to figure out how much of the wealth increase (in the past couple of decades) came from asset price inflation, mainly real estate, rather than accumulation. 400% in addition to consumer price inflation? And this is largely the aim and result of low-interest rate policies by central banks since 1987, in the aftermath of Black Monday. The ratio Kapital/NonKapital exploded right there... And had Piketty looked at his "inequality" and Debt-to-GDP he would have perhaps seen the real evil: asset inflation with-stop-from-Central-banks.
PPPS- Rething about Piketty's book, and his "data", one wonders whether pages and pages of correlation-implies-causation can sway economists when the message fits their agenda (dispossess the risk-taking money by nonrisktakers is something that dissgusts me) but more rigorous work can leave them indifferent.
PPPPS- One reason I left data out of The Black Swan (except for illustrative purposes) is that it seems to me that people flood their story with data in the absence of logical argument. Just a little bit of data is needed when one is right (disconfirmatory empiricism).

11 comments:

Emily V. Kyles said...

Football betting is more open than online gambling Latest Golden Euro casino .Bet on programs through famous channels in Malaysia and around the world. https://mega888.live/latest-golden-euro-casino-daily-and-monthly-bonuses-2019-250-match-xmas-bonus-2/

Ron Thompson said...

Fun things help to attempt to get familiar with betting games. " SCR888 download" Numerous individuals are keen on betting, regardless of whether they can comprehend the purpose behind betting, possibly there are things that can make us see the improvement pattern of training. https://sandramhoward.page.tl/

james said...

Or favorite 918 kiss download occupation to relax and get the body ready to act the battery. https://justpaste.it/52bky

hunnysah said...

In lotto games, you're not looking for a lucky number. You're playing by hoping for a mystrikingly combination of numbers that will come up together in the sequence. If you pick a lucky number and you hit on another one, chances are that you've just won a single game.
http://luckywinnerlist-com.mystrikingly.com/

Unknown said...

promotion Strategy is not something that is learned in a classroom or a event textbook. publicity strategy is actually a comprehensive, long-term, proactive open and a game plot of any business or company as soon as the ultimate point of reaching a competitive edge by knowing the desires <a href="https://mowilaw.post-blogs.com/news</a>
and needs of consumers. marketing Strategy is the art and science of knowing your audience, accord their needs and maximizing the use of handy resources to achieve them. It is virtually the money up front of an understanding with you and the customer that lead to a win-win issue for both of you.

Unknown said...

Marketing company strategy is actually a comprehensive, long-term, proactive approach and a game plan of any business or company with the ultimate objective of reaching a competitive edge by knowing the desires and needs of consumers. Marketing Strategy is the art and science of knowing your audience, understanding their needs, and maximizing the use of available resources to reach them. It is about the development of an understanding between you and the customer that leads to a win-win situation for both of you.

Unknown said...

Advertising system is really an extensive, long haul, proactive methodology and a strategy of any business or organization with a definitive target of arriving at a serious edge by knowing the cravings and necessities of buyers. Promoting Strategy is the craftsmanship and study of knowing your crowd, understanding their necessities and amplifying the utilization of accessible assets to contact them. best companies for digital marketing It is about the advancement of a comprehension among you and the client that lead to a mutually advantageous arrangement for both of you.

Heather J. Buchanan said...

Wreck fix Process, after you have totally on a shop you can call the tow company to forgiveness the vehicle and have the vehicle towed to the fix shop. The shop will lid all the tows and storage and go to them to the claim. At this point, you can get your rental car if you have the coverage. see post Getting rental coverage is a fine idea if you don't have another car to use indeed of an accident. Your insurance company will insure any vehicle you borrow for full coverage subsequently a $500.00 deductible once you're having your car repaired even if you achieve not have full coverage upon your personal vehicle. consequently, if you have a pal later than a car and you want to borrow it, it's insured for full coverage as long as your car is in for repair and swine repaired. They will ensure any rental cars you rent for the same period. discover this info here

jhon said...

When you enter a house that has been cared for by the hands of professionals the quality of the take steps is rapidly evident. A DIY job can never have the polish or shine of a professional project completed by dedicated experts of their craft. Painting is roughly more than just covering up imperfections or surcharge a splash of color. A professional painting backing can transform an entire house and create a number of performing arts themes from a soothing, relaxing bathroom to a vibrant, looking for argument lithe area. Whether you wish to make your own personal color plot or replicate an exquisite example from a photo we will help your house total its full potential. our website

Anonymous said...

Thanks for sharing this kind of information with us.
This link

joneysin said...

The exact amount of nutrients your dog can get depends on the amount and type of filler from the brand you're feeding it. Dogs can generally absorb almost all of the carbohydrates in some grains, such as white rice, but they cannot digest many others, such as peanut husks.have a peek here

LinkWithin

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...